Sonny and Terry shared the same heart. They died the same way. And there’s one other thing these two men shared: a wife. A heart transplant transforms Sonny Graham’s fate when he reaches out to the widow of his heart donor. What follows is trumpeted by local papers as a miraculous love story. But court filings expose a more troubled reality. Friends and family report a worrying change in Sonny. Then, he dies by suicide—the exact same fate, it turns out, as his heart donor, Terry Cottle. The families of the two men are suddenly bound together by disturbing questions. Others speculate that Sonny’s new heart might have been carrying Terry’s traumas. Are the two men’s deaths just a coincidence, or are there darker forces at work? Heart is an Apple Original podcast produced by Plan B and Blanchard House. Follow and listen on Apple Podcasts. http://apple.co/Heart
What this show covers
heart transplantgrieffamily estrangementinvestigationpersonality changeTerry Cottlesuicideunresolved questionsfamily tragedyfamily mysterypsychological questionstrue crimetrue storymysteryrelationships
What listeners will find here
A daughter investigates whether a heart transplant changed her father forever
Michelle reels from her father Sonny’s affair with the widow of his heart donor, then begins her own investigation after his death by suicide. The episode digs into grief, family rupture, and the unsettling question of whether a transplanted heart could alter personality.
The life and unraveling of the man behind Sonny Graham’s transplanted heart
This episode turns to Terry Cottle, the man whose heart later beat in Sonny Graham’s chest. It traces Terry’s life from devoted husband and father to a painful rupture, ending with his death by suicide at 33 and troubling questions about his final hours.
A heart transplant, a marriage, and two eerily linked deaths
This episode introduces the story of Sonny Graham, whose heart transplant connects him to donor Terry Cottle in ways that become increasingly unsettling. What begins as a widely celebrated love story with Terry’s widow turns into a mystery shaped by court filings, family concerns, and haunting parallels.
A lifesaving transplant leads to a haunting, deeply unsettling connection
A heart transplant saves Sonny Graham, a larger-than-life figure on Hilton Head Island, but his search for his donor’s widow changes everything. The episode sets up a mystery around love, loss, and a death that eerily mirrors the donor’s own fate.
Episodes
More like Heart
Dateline NBC
NBC News
Serialously with Annie Elise
Annie Elise & Audioboom Studios
Secrets We Keep
LiSTNR
Russell Brand: On Trial
Sky News
Shattered Lives
Reach Ireland Podcasts
Hidden True Crime
Hidden True Crime | Daylight Media
Last Podcast On The Left
The Last Podcast Network
This Feels Criminal: A True Crime Podcast (Formerly Killer Queens)
This Feels Criminal | Formerly Killer Queens
The Binge Cases: Doctor Billions
Sony Music Entertainment
British Murders with Stuart Blues
Stuart Blues