Hosts Mike Ferguson and Mike Gibson guide you through the most interesting true crime stories. This is a true crime podcast that spares none of the details and delves into what makes these killers tick. Join us for a good mix of lesser known cases as well as our take on what we call the "Big Timers". We don't take ourselves too seriously but we take true crime very seriously.
What this show covers
cold casemissing personsMorgan Bauerinvestigationforensicsfamily advocacyhomicide investigationUtahDNA evidenceforensic genealogymurder investigationbaseballArizonaDernell StensonNicole Lovell
What listeners will find here
A seven-year mystery shifts when new evidence changes Morgan Bauer’s case
Morgan Bauer’s disappearance follows a 19-year-old who moved from South Dakota to the Atlanta area in 2016 and vanished less than two weeks later. The episode traces the long cold-case investigation and the 2023 breakthrough that led to arrests and answers about her fate.
A 1985 disappearance that took decades to be recognized as homicide
David Reed vanished during a bike ride in Pennsylvania in 1985, and his death was initially left unexplained. This episode follows how family persistence, new witness information, and modern forensic review changed the case more than 20 years later.
A cold case, a rare-book store, and the DNA breakthrough that changed everything
The episode examines the 2010 murder of Sherry Black inside her South Salt Lake City rare-book store and the long, frustrating search for her killer. It follows the case from strong but unusable physical evidence to the forensic genetic genealogy breakthrough that revived the investigation years later.
A rising baseball career ends in a killing that quickly grows more complicated
Dernell Stenson follows the brief Major League breakthrough and shocking 2003 murder of the 25-year-old Cincinnati Reds player. The episode traces how a case first seen as a random carjacking expanded to include death threats, stolen vehicles, cash, multiple suspects, and a tangled past relationship.
A missing teen, a secret Kik contact, and a case built through digital evidence
Nicole Lovell centers on the 2016 disappearance and murder of 13-year-old Nicole Lovell in Virginia. The episode follows how her online messages, GPS data, surveillance footage, and forensic evidence led investigators to two Virginia Tech students and exposed the risks facing vulnerable kids online.
Episodes
More like True Crime All The Time
Dateline NBC
NBC News
Russell Brand: On Trial
Sky News
British Murders with Stuart Blues
Stuart Blues
Last Podcast On The Left
The Last Podcast Network
This Feels Criminal: A True Crime Podcast (Formerly Killer Queens)
This Feels Criminal | Formerly Killer Queens
History's Greatest Mysteries
The HISTORY Channel | Rewind Studios
Not Just A Terrible Story
Terrible Story Productions
Hidden True Crime
Hidden True Crime | Daylight Media
Serialously with Annie Elise
Annie Elise & Audioboom Studios
Secrets We Keep
LiSTNR