Murder With My Husband

The Borden murders episode revisits the 1892 killings of Andrew and Abby Borden and the case that made Lizzie Borden infamous. It digs into family conflict, money, and contradictory accounts while comparing the historical record with Netflix’s version of the story.

Christine Banfield and Joseph Ryan’s killings sit at the center of a case involving a secret affair, catfishing, and a plot more tangled than it first appears. Garrett and Payton dig into how those threads connect in a double homicide that sounds stranger the deeper it gets.

Fahim Saleh is the subject of this episode, which explores the shocking murder of the tech CEO inside his Manhattan apartment. Payton and Garrett dig into a case that combines ambition, success, and a deeply disturbing crime.

The episode centers on the murder of Ali Kemp, a college student killed while working a summer job at a neighborhood pool. Payton and Garrett explore the case and the unusual billboard effort that became a key part of identifying her killer.

Thad Reynolds and his high school sweetheart Michelle reunite after divorce and remarry, only for their second chance at love to spiral into a deadly love triangle. Payton and Garrett dig into how a rekindled relationship became a murder case.